Which Debt Should You Pay Off First?

November 2020
Between credit cards, student loans, car loans and mortgages, you’re probably carrying some debt. On the surface, managing your debt can seem relatively easy — just make minimum payments. However, if you’d like to pay down your debts, you have some choices to make. Namely, which debt should you prioritize? Here’s a look at the advantages and disadvantages of each.

Pay off the highest interest first

If you want to make your money go the furthest, personal finance website The Motley Fool recommends paying off the highest interest debt first. With this strategy, you’ll get rid of the costliest debt first, so you’ll save money in the long run. However, there are potential downsides to this strategy. Your highest-interest debt may be your largest debt — such as a mortgage or a student loan. Bankrate contributor Nicole Dieker explains that it can be extremely discouraging to spend years putting your money towards paying down a large debt to end up only covering the interest.

Pay off the lowest debt first

If you enjoy the feeling of quick accomplishments, consider paying off your lowest debts first. This gives you a feeling of momentum that can be encouraging. Although you’ll ultimately pay more in interest over the life of the loan, The Balance contributor Miriam Caldwell advises you to knock out your lowest debts. In addition to giving you a feel-good rush of emotions, this can help eliminate troublesome calls from collection agencies.

Pay off high-credit-utilization debt

If you’re one of the many borrowers who’d like a higher credit score, consider paying down your debt with the goal of improving your credit utilization ratio. You’ll have a higher credit score if your credit cards aren’t maxed out. And once you have a higher credit score, you’ll be able to secure a better interest rate on your future loans. If you’re interested in taking this route, The Motley Fool recommends that you prioritize paying down credit cards that utilize more than 30 percent of their credit limit.

Account for tax breaks

While paying interest can feel like bleeding money, it can come with tax breaks depending on the type of loan. For instance, paying your student loan interest provides a tax break. Although this doesn’t mean you should neglect paying down your student loans by only paying for interest, Caldwell explains that you may see more financial advantages to tackling your credit cards first.

When you consider your unique goals and financial situation, you may find that a hybrid approach suits your needs. For instance, you could pay down a few small debts, then switch gears and chip away at your high-interest loans.

For guidance on paying down your debts, you can search online for a debt repayment calculator, which can give you a clearer idea of how much interest you’ll be paying, how large your monthly payments should be and how long it will take to pay off your debts. You can also consult with one of Waukesha State Bank’s personal bankers, who can look at your unique situation and help you decide which options are best for you. Contact us today at (262) 549-8500 or click here to schedule an appointment.